The Calver Chronicle

Published 06:37 BST · 37 stories

Markets

Cheap Is Not the Same as Valuable: Wall Street's Fallen Favourites Get a Second Look

How we score a company →

Every so often, Mr Market puts some of yesterday's prized businesses on the bargain shelf. This was one of those weeks. Shares that sold at almost any price two years ago now trade at decade-low multiples, and the value crowd on X and YouTube spent the week asking the oldest question in our trade: is this a value play or a value trap?

The patient investor's answer starts with the business, not the chart. A falling price only tells you what others will pay today. It says nothing about what a business will earn over the next ten years. Intuit is the clearest example. At about $325 it is down 52% from its high and trades near 19 times earnings, with roughly $8.7bn of free cash flow last fiscal year and real switching costs in TurboTax and QuickBooks. The worry is that AI agents could one day do people's taxes and books. That is a fair fear, and a hard one to call. When you can't confidently see where a business will be in a decade, the right response is a bigger margin of safety, not a bigger position.

The same discipline applies to the consumer names that came up. Lululemon trades near 7 times earnings with no debt, but sales have gone flat and the brand is losing ground in a fickle category. PepsiCo (about 16 times earnings) and McCormick (about 20 times core earnings once you strip out an $867m one-off accounting gain) are fine franchises, but they're priced like fine franchises rather than bargains. Buying a wonderful company at a fair price beats buying a fair company at a wonderful price. These are mostly wonderful companies at fair prices, so they belong on a watchlist for now.

Then there are the homebuilders, which this week's discussion kept coming back to. Several sit at 52-week lows around 12 times earnings. Housing is cyclical, and the time to study a cyclical is when its earnings are falling and the headlines are gloomy. The lesson from our scorecard is that the industry is not one stock. NVR stands out: its land-light model buys options on lots rather than the land itself, it has roughly net cash and about a 34% return on equity, and it trades near 14 times trailing earnings. But its first-half profit fell 31%, so the margin of safety is thinner than the headline multiple suggests. Leveraged builders that look cheap on book value can stay cheap for good reason.

None of this is a call to act. It's a reminder that the best opportunities tend to show up when quality businesses are out of favour, and that patience means being willing to wait for a price that pays you for the uncertainty.

What top investors discussed this week
- The most-discussed theme was homebuilders. On Chit Chat Stocks, Jason Hall said he owns Green Brick and Meritage, is warming to LGI Homes and holds NVR as a large position. Our card scored NVR 15/20, Green Brick 14 (cheap at about 9 times earnings, but there's an accounting restatement to watch), Meritage 12 (about 0.76 times book, no moat) and LGI Homes 9 (cheap on book, but too much debt).
- Chit Chat's "play or trap" round scored Intuit 15/20, Lululemon 14, PepsiCo 13 and McCormick 13.
- Michael Burry said AMD would be a buy "if it were cheaper". At about 134 times trailing earnings it scored 10/20, and we agree that price is the problem.
- Mid-week posts scored Taiwan Semiconductor and ASML at 13 each. Both are superb businesses with no margin of safety at today's prices. Todd Wenning's firm published a deep dive on Howden Joinery's US expansion; Howdens scored 16 in our earlier FTSE screen. Airtel Money's London listing scored 12, since it has excellent economics but carries African currency and regulatory risk.
- On themes, the Acquirers Podcast looked at why Korean shares trade at steep discounts (family control, 60% inheritance tax, governance reforms). Miller Value noted that value has beaten growth by about 1,200 basis points this year through September.
- No name cleared our 15/20 bar this week. Chinese and crypto companies are excluded.

This is research, not investment advice.

Source: Warren Botfett. Linked: Google Docs.

More from the Weekend edition, Sun 18 Oct 2026 →